In post1789 french history federalism was linked with counter. The centralizationdecentralization issue european commission. Federalism and decentralization philippsuniversitat marburg. Federalism, decentralization and macroeconomic performance. Decentralization, not federalism, key to ph progress.
He sees federalism as the next logical step to the decentralization of political powers to local governments through devolution. In this political science course you will learn about the twin concepts of federalism and decentralization. Regional conflict and the origins of argentine federalism with edward gibson, and reallocative federalism. The practical distinction between federalism and decentralization is a little blurred, particularly in african cases where federalism and decentralization arrive together as part of the big bang of democratic reforms of the 1990s. Subnational state transformation in uganda janet i. Routledge studies in federalism and decentralization. Request pdf comparative federalism and decentralization. It is grounded in a clear distinction between federations, particular kinds of states, and federalism, the thinking that drives and promotes them. In the empirical field, scholars focus on fiscal decentralization and degree of. After discussing the analytical issues related to the specific nature of decentralization in federal systems, the paper examines two sets of policy issues. By decentralization i mean the transfer of authority and responsibility for public functions from the central government to intermediate and local governments or quasiindependent government organizations and or the private sector the world bank, 2002.
Theres fundamental difference between decentralisation or. Or are the answers to these questions conditional on other more important factors. There are also new approaches regarding the relation between decentralization and democracy and sustainable development. They are responsible for creating a number of obstacles in the functioning of federalism in brazil in the recent time. The evolution of american federalism american government.
Rieck interstate functional economic unions are recognizable in todays world. The course on pakistani federalism and decentralization is part of undps project strengthening participatory federalism and decentralization aimed at providing support for the implementation of the 18th amendment by informing, facilitating, and optimizing the process of. Decentralization, not federalism, is the remedy for such problem. Federalism, decentralization and conflict management in multicultural societies international community serap bindebir, mia handshin, miodrag jovanovic, christian e. Decentralization and centralization in a federal system. Towards a theoretical framework decentralization is the most popular concept in the contemporary period and is linked to development and democracy. The building blocks of fiscal federalism 10 assigning expenditure responsibilities 10 raising revenue 11 overseeing subnational borrowing 12 designing intergovernmental transfers 12 assembling the building blocks. The series publishes outstanding scholarship on federalism and decentralization, defined broadly, and is open to theoretical, empirical, philosophical, and historical works. A new examination of contemporary federalism and federation, which delivers a detailed theoretical study underpinned by fresh case studies. Paolo dardanelli, john kincaid the routledge studies in federalism and decentralization series publishes outstanding scholarship on federalism and decentralization, defined broadly, and is open to theoretical, empirical, philosophical, and historical works. Political decentralization approaches generally distinguish federations from unitary states capturing the degree of subnational power e. Federalism to decentralization comparative constitution project.
Providing both a detailed theoretical examination and fresh case studies, it clearly distinguishes between federation, a particular kind of state, and federalism, the thinking that drives and promotes it. She specializes in issues of federalism, intergovernmental relations, and decentralization, with a research focus on latin america. Ethnic decentralization and the challenges of inclusive governance in multiethnic cities. Difference between decentralization and federalism the. Political scientists and economists have developed a wealth of theories to explain the. Federalism, decentralisation and corruption munich. During nixons administration, general revenue sharing programs were created that distributed funds to the state and local governments with minimal restrictions on how. Federalism and decentralization a critical survey of. Evaluating africas track record from universiteit leiden. Does federalism preserve markets and spur economic growth. Federalism and decentralization konradadenauerstiftung. Comparative federalism and decentralization on meaning and measurement. This discussion paper was prepared under dg ecfins 20142015 fellowship initiative growth, integration and structural convergence revisited.
Federalism overview in the pr eviou s chapter, we noted that v ertical divi sion of power among different levels of government is one of the major forms of powersharing in modern democr acies. How federalism adapts to changing and more varied circumstances. The united states and european union in comparative perspective r. Mobility and redistribution, journal of political economy 99, 4. Federalism offered a solution to citizens fears that they would be ruled by majorities from different regions and different interest and values vii. Exploring linkages between federalism and democracy. Decentralization, interregional redistribution and income convergence fabio padovano fiscal reform in spain accomplishments and challenges edited by jorge martinez vazquez and jose felix sanzsanz fiscal federalism and political decentralization lessons from spain, germany and canada edited by nuria bosch and jose m. In this paper, we critically survey the existing indicators for both federalism and fiscal decentralization. Political decentralization is sometimes known by different names, including federalism riker 1964, policy decentralization rodden 2004 or decisionmaking decentralization treisman 2002. View comparative federalism research papers on academia. Federalism, decentralization and conflict management.
A comparative regional study routledge studies in federalism and decentralization. Welcome to the international political science associations research committee on comparative federalism and multilevel governance rc28. This paper analyzes agreements between governments that determine the division of policymaking power between central and regional governments. Dual federalism the layer cake metaphor is a view that holds the constitution is a compact. Week 2 23 and 25 september what federalism is, and how it works. While a conceptual difference between the two terms is important, the practice can sometimes blend into each other. In comparing decentralization or devolution with federalism it can be observed that there is a fundamental difference.
Find out about our activities and how to become a member. Week 3 30 september and 2 october the growing diversity of federal experiments. Decentralization or devolution of powers decentralisation or devolution can simply be defined as the transfer of part of the powers of t. Semantic scholar extracted view of comparative federalism and decentralization. Jan 08, 2015 decentralization or devolution of powers and federalism differ fundamentally, lets look at them separately. Her recent publications include unity by the stick. Using a newly assembled dataset containing data for up to 174 countries, we revisit the empirical evidence and seek to explain some of the inconsistent results that exist in the literature. Brancati 2008, or use a combination of continuous measures of fiscal decentralization and federalism dummy variables anderson 2006. The basis of the model is the theory of public finance musgrave 1959.
The political economy of federalism and decentralization. Combining federalism and decentralization sage journals. Federalism a characteristic element of swiss forest policy 1. Comparative federalism and multilevel governance the. In development process, scholars and experts consider decentralization as the most significant one because it can eradicate poverty, environmental.
Federalism and decentralization in subsaharan africa. Decentralization or devolution of powers and federalism differ fundamentally, lets look at them separately. Strengthening participatory federalism and decentralization. Rethinking decentralization in developing countries. The decentralization is a broad concept, which can be a form of administrative, political, spatial, and fiscal. Importance of federalism generally and in current discussion in a description of the swiss political system, one of the first features mentioned will be federalism.
We find that not only results differ due to the use of different specifications and data but more importantly because. Administrative decentralization versus fiscal federalism. Federalism to decentralization cheryl saunders melbourne law school introduction the functions of government that a state performs can be decentralized in various ways and to varying degrees. Above all, rather than enhancing the independent authority of state and municipal governments, decentralization often creates a more complex. Rc28 is the premier scholarly network worldwide for the study of federalism and multilevel governance. There is probably no field of swiss policy that is not influenced by the fact that switzerland is a federation. Federalism, regional redistribution, and country stability. We investigate the empirical relationship between decentralisation and corruption. The course on pakistani federalism and decentralization is part of undps project strengthening participatory federalism and decentralization aimed at providing support for the implementation of the 18th amendment by informing, facilitating, and optimizing the process of transition management at federal. Our analysis demonstrates that initial circumstances and political risks affect the degree of centralization that will be adopted, and that asymmetric forms of federalism are often consequences of ongoing negotiations between regional. Apr, 2012 political decentralization approaches generally distinguish federations from unitary states capturing the degree of subnational power e. Federalism is a public sector reform intervention to deepen decentralization and enhance autonomy of local governments. Federalism, economic growth, and governance arguments about mobility and competition have led to arguments linking federalism to. Vertical competition in a unitary state archive ouverte hal.
Comparative federalism uses a comparative approach to explore the contemporary nature and meanings of federalism and federation. This paper discusses the contradictory impulses towards decentralization and centralization in brazil during the 1990s and early 2000s. If anything, the discourse on federalism will continue to stir the debate of the need to shift powers and authorities to subnational. The paper presents a comparative analysis of the various institutional systems. The emerging view of decentralization shows an organic, intertwined transfer of politi cal, fiscal, and policy autonomy. An interesting article, if somewhat involved, by ilija g. In this chapter, we focus on this form of powersharing. Decentralization and federalism in brazil prakash chandra jha the present article examines the various factors which have led to fiscal and political decentralization in brazil. A comparative regional study routledge studies in federalism and decentralization kefale, asnake on. Successful decentralization depends on institutionspeci. From the perspective of the constituent states that make up a federation, federalism constrains democracy because requirements of federal law may limit a.
Comparative federalism and decentralization on meaning and measurement jonathan rodden the basic structure of governance is being transformed in countries around the world as authority and resources migrate from central to subnational governments. The purpose of this paper is to provide a broad comparativehistorical. Our analysis demonstrates that initial circumstances and political risks affect the degree of centralization that will be adopted, and that asymmetric forms of federalism are often consequences of ongoing negotiations between regional and central. Decentralization or devolution of powers decentralisation or devolution can simply be defined as the transfer of part of the powers of the central government to regional or state authorities and it is in response to demands for diversity. Philippine politicoadministrative history has shown that the decentralization of powers to subnational governments has been a continuing demand of local governments as part of the clamor for autonomy. Charles wyplosz the graduate institute, geneva applies federalism principles to crucial questions of fiscal policy, fiscal discipline and structural reforms in the eu. Federalism and decentralization part 1 welcome to this. Adding another legislative chamber or an executive with a veto to our analysis will only improve the ability of federalist systems to meet the participation, sovereignty and efficiency. Policy decisions made by state governments will be decided by their separate legislatures. Decentralization is often viewed as a shift of authority towards local governments and away from central governments, with total government authority over society. It was, as customary in the soviet bloc, merely an instrument for manipulating the relations among ethnic groups, but it was. Publications comparative federalism and multilevel. Constitutional frameworks for the middle east and north africa about this report the constitutional transitions clinic back office has, from 2011 to 2014, prepared. Book series routledge studies in federalism and decentralization.
This chapter outlines some of the approaches that are most widely used and illustrates their use through case studies. Federalism is a political concept used to describe a system of government in which sovereignty is constitutionally divided between a central governing authority and constituent political units such as the states in south sudan. What is the difference between decentralisation and. Federalism is a structuring principle which is appropriate for organizing selfgoverning communities into a union, said mendoza. Federalism and decentralization in subsaharan africa 1st. A challenge to political decentralization in a unitary state article pdf available in philippine journal of public administration 332. We argue that federalism is a constitutional institution whereas decentralization is the outcome of a policy choice and that the two ought to be systematically distinguished because decentralization can also occur in nonfederally. Reliable crossnational data on decentralization and federalism are scarce, and the concepts are often assumed to be complementary or even interchangeable. Does federalism restrict the growth of the public sector.
200 1333 320 807 509 616 1365 313 1557 525 72 313 811 1280 1487 1446 136 1164 1648 1647 1466 819 39 503 96 789 1631 1505 120 1598 85 279 340 1516 414 1405 717 532 1077 8 658 906 169 564 398 1061 799 578 656 1051